Skip to content 
Austin’s mother came home that day to find her world shattered. The son she had kissed goodbye that morning was gone. And the boy she trusted, the one she loved, now stood accused of murder.
Inside the Trial: Tears, Anguish, and a Divided Nation
The trial that followed was a crucible of emotion. Dylan’s defense insisted he hadn’t meant to kill Austin—that he was overwhelmed, immature, and emotionally underdeveloped. In court, Dylan cried openly, pleaded for forgiveness, and showed remorse. His visible breakdown led many to ask: Was this a calculating criminal or a lost child who had made a horrible, irreversible mistake?
But for the jury, the facts outweighed emotion. Dylan Schumaker was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 25 years to life. Yet, upon appeal, that sentence was later reduced to 18 years—an acknowledgment of his young age and the complexity of his psychological and emotional development at the time.